Transcript of PB minutes 12/19/2007
December 19, 2007
members present: chairman Edsall, Georgia mingle, Tom Ingersoll, Andy Biinsley
absent: Karen Bourcy
chairman Edsall began the meeting with asking if planning board members have comments on the draft environmental impact statement that had been delivered to the planning board by BP alternative energy for their Cape Vincent wind project.
Member Binsley commented any would like to see more pictures taken from the center of the project. The Huff Road, Bedford corner's area).
Chairman Edsall remarked that, Bernier Carr had sent a letter commenting on the DEIS. Mr. Edsall also remarked that there would be more studies, forthcoming and that this is just a " draft" document. There was a discussion of supplemental sound studies.
Member Bourcy arrived 7:05 PM.
Chairman Edsall asked the Lord. If the document met the standard to start the public review process. He stated again that is not a complete document, it is a " draft" document.
Member Ingersoll made a motion to accept the attached resolution per 6NYCCR617.9. Member Mingle made the second.
The results of the vote were:
chairman Edsall abstain Ingersoll, yes Binsley yes Bourcy yes, Mingle, yes, the resolution passes.
Edsall announced that the public comment period for the document would enter February 29, 2008 at the close of the mail day. There would be no e-mail or fax comments accepted. Local, would be accepted only at the public hearing. The public hearing will be January 26, 2008 at recreation Park, James St., Cape Vincent, from 9 AM to noon. A sign- in sheet would be used to establish the order of speakers. Each speaker would be allowed 3 min. If time allowed, each person would be given an additional 3 min. after the list has been followed the first time. Mr. Jim Madden, representing BP alternative would be given limited time at the beginning of the meeting to it introduce his project.
Comments would be restricted to the DEIS. Comments concerning proposed pilot agreements, or contracts to protect roads, for example, would not be relevant at the time and would not therefore be accepted.
Chairman Edsall outlined the process for public comment concerning the DEIS. There would be one public hearing in January on the DEIS. Because the he did a scoping document. There would only be one hearing on the DEIS there will be a second hearing a final EIS is produced. There would be a third hearing. If the project proceeds to the site plan review process.
Mr. Madden was structured to deliver one copy of the DEIS student Town Clerk, as well as the Bernier Carr comment letter. Two. Copies were to be delivered to the Cape Vincent community library one copy was to go to the lyme free library. Other copies were to be delivered to the other involved agencies previously identified. Mr. Madden was to see that the TEC received their copy in me appropriate office. BP is also to have the document on a website and " up and running." by December 28, 2007. Mr. Madden is to get a signed receipt for all books placed as well as any supplements that are added at a later date.
Chairman Edsall explained that the planning board will review all the comments received separate area list of items that need attention. If at the time of the final EIS. There are still deficient items, there will be an additional public hearing.
Mr. Madden explained that there was no array map in the DEIS. He explained that BP has not yet made a decision as to which specific turbines would be used in this project. I until that decision is made, it is not practical to develop a map that indicates the space between turbines or their placement. When the map is produced, it will be made available to the planning board and the public in the placed with the DEIS. He will notify the planning board when the map is available.
After a question from the audience about the lack of information, chairman Edsall explained again that, by law, the planning board was obligated to bring in the public review process and the public should feel free to comment on the other sections of the document.
Another audience member asked where the supplemental documents would be placed and how would the public be notified that they were available. Mr. Madden said that they would be placed at the usual location and beheaded in to the planning board. He asked the address of the website. He said that it would be a link from the BP alternative energy.com site.
Member Ingersoll made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Member mingle made the second. All were in favor.
Meeting adjourned at 7:27 PM
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Resolved, that the document " draft environmental impact statement" " DEIS" submitted by Cape Vincent wind power project (BP alternative energy North America, Incorporated.) Is complete. It is ," complete"
in that it is adequate with respect to its scope and content for the purposes of commencing public review.
Per 6 NYC RR 617.9
Edsall – abstain
Ingersoll – yes.
Binsley – yes.
Mingle – yes.
December 19, 2007
Wednesday, December 19, 2007
Thursday, November 15, 2007
FOREIGN-OWNED COMPANIES DESTROYING DREAMS
Published
November 15, 2007
Watertown Times
Section letters
What makes America the greatest country in the
world is being able to live your own American dream, something that you've
worked for, no matter the size.
Most of us
work a lifetime to achieve our goals. One dream for some of us brought up in
the north country is to spend our winters in a warmer, gentler climate and our
summers in one of the best-kept secrets of the north - on the lakes, bays and
rivers of north Jefferson County.
But when the
state, with the help of a few local landowners, decides to turn the pristine
areas into industrial wind complexes, all our lives are forever changed. I have
the greatest respect for our local farmers, as I worked for a couple of them
for nearly 10 years as a kid while living on the shores of Three Mile Bay
during the summer.
Wind History ~ 2007~ DEC GRANNIS rejects Lyme's plea for lead agency for bp's Cape Wind
This is a continuation of the timeline sent to me by
November 15, 2007:
NYSDEC Commissioner Grannis writes Towns of Lyme and Cape Vincent regarding his decision on Lyme’s lead-agency dispute over BP Project. Cape Planning Board claimed lead-agency status within the Town of Lyme because Lyme PB did not respond within 30 days to Cape’s request for lead-agency status. Grannis rejects Lyme’s plea to have lead-agency authority over that portion of the BP Cape-Lyme project within its bounds. It remains to be understood, however, whether Commissioner Grannis was aware of Edsall’s financial ties to BP and the potential conflicts of two other members of the Cape Planning Board. Moreover, if he had been known about these conflicts, would this have changed his findings in this dispute.
November 15, 2007:
NYSDEC Commissioner Grannis writes Towns of Lyme and Cape Vincent regarding his decision on Lyme’s lead-agency dispute over BP Project. Cape Planning Board claimed lead-agency status within the Town of Lyme because Lyme PB did not respond within 30 days to Cape’s request for lead-agency status. Grannis rejects Lyme’s plea to have lead-agency authority over that portion of the BP Cape-Lyme project within its bounds. It remains to be understood, however, whether Commissioner Grannis was aware of Edsall’s financial ties to BP and the potential conflicts of two other members of the Cape Planning Board. Moreover, if he had been known about these conflicts, would this have changed his findings in this dispute.
Friday, November 2, 2007
Cape Vincent race centers on wind power
2 November 2007
Wind power has turned the race for Cape Vincent town supervisor into perhaps the most contentious and controversial political campaign in the North Country.
“Everybody’s chosen sides. You’re either for windmills or you’re against windmills,” said local resident Harvey White.
The race for supervisor pits four-term Democratic incumbent Thomas Rienbeck against Republican John DeFrancesco.
Both support wind power development for the town.
However, the candidates’ political signs have been defaced or stolen.
There have been accusations of conflicts of interest and allegations of dirty politics.
Then there’s the Wind Power Ethics Group, which is suing the town zoning board.
The suit challenges the town’s zoning law that allows windmills within agricultural and residential zones.
“Had it not been for outside pressures of this anti-wind power group, there would be zoning regulations in place in Cape Vincent today,” said Rienbeck.
Some members of the Wind Power Ethics Group have backed DeFrancesco, who said he also has the votes of wind power supporters, Republicans and even Democrats.
“I’m for wind turbines, but they have to be done correctly. If they’re not done correctly and we don’t have good leadership, we will not reach the potential and it’ll be a disaster for us,” said DeFrancesco.
Wind power is also affecting certain members of the town council, who have been advised to abstain from voting on wind farm development due to conflicts of interest.
Two of the council members are seeking reelection and are being challenged by candidates who say they have no conflicts of interest.
“The whole atmosphere of Cape Vincent is one of community and that’s what I hope we get back to after the situation is resolved here,” said local resident Mary Hamilton.
wwnytv.net link to article not available
2 November 2007
Wind power has turned the race for Cape Vincent town supervisor into perhaps the most contentious and controversial political campaign in the North Country.
“Everybody’s chosen sides. You’re either for windmills or you’re against windmills,” said local resident Harvey White.
The race for supervisor pits four-term Democratic incumbent Thomas Rienbeck against Republican John DeFrancesco.
Both support wind power development for the town.
However, the candidates’ political signs have been defaced or stolen.
There have been accusations of conflicts of interest and allegations of dirty politics.
Then there’s the Wind Power Ethics Group, which is suing the town zoning board.
The suit challenges the town’s zoning law that allows windmills within agricultural and residential zones.
“Had it not been for outside pressures of this anti-wind power group, there would be zoning regulations in place in Cape Vincent today,” said Rienbeck.
Some members of the Wind Power Ethics Group have backed DeFrancesco, who said he also has the votes of wind power supporters, Republicans and even Democrats.
“I’m for wind turbines, but they have to be done correctly. If they’re not done correctly and we don’t have good leadership, we will not reach the potential and it’ll be a disaster for us,” said DeFrancesco.
Wind power is also affecting certain members of the town council, who have been advised to abstain from voting on wind farm development due to conflicts of interest.
Two of the council members are seeking reelection and are being challenged by candidates who say they have no conflicts of interest.
“The whole atmosphere of Cape Vincent is one of community and that’s what I hope we get back to after the situation is resolved here,” said local resident Mary Hamilton.
wwnytv.net link to article not available
2 November 2007
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
CHAIR OF GOP CONSIDERS RESIGNING
Published: October 30, 2007
Watertown Daily Times
CHAIR OF GOP CONSIDERS RESIGNING
CAPE VINCENT RACES: MASON SAYS ELECTION ATMOSPHERE IS TAXING
By KELLY VADNEY
TIMES STAFF WRITER
CAPE VINCENT -- The chairman of the town's Republican Committee is contemplating resignation.
Marty T. Mason, who is also a town councilman seeking re-election, said the atmosphere surrounding political races this year is enough to push him from his post.
"I'm frustrated with the whole election," he said. "I'm counting the minutes down."
Wind farm development has been the major issue in the races for supervisor and Town Council.
Continue reading via the [WDT archives]
Watertown Daily Times
CHAIR OF GOP CONSIDERS RESIGNING
CAPE VINCENT RACES: MASON SAYS ELECTION ATMOSPHERE IS TAXING
By KELLY VADNEY
TIMES STAFF WRITER
CAPE VINCENT -- The chairman of the town's Republican Committee is contemplating resignation.
Marty T. Mason, who is also a town councilman seeking re-election, said the atmosphere surrounding political races this year is enough to push him from his post.
"I'm frustrated with the whole election," he said. "I'm counting the minutes down."
Wind farm development has been the major issue in the races for supervisor and Town Council.
Continue reading via the [WDT archives]
Sunday, October 28, 2007
WIND POWER DRIVING ISSUE IN CAPE VINCENT
Wind Power Driving Issue in Cape Race
Conflicts Alleged: Two Town Council Candidates Have Contract
Wind Farm Turbine Developer
October 28,2007
by Kelly Vadney
Times staff writer
Cape Vincent – – it's not just wind power, but charges of
conflicts of interest regarding wind farm development, that are fueling a four
– way race for two open Town Council seats.
Incumbents Marty T. Mason, a Republican and Donald J Mason,
a Democrat, who are not related, are seeking re-– election. They are being
challenged by Republican Gregory L. Hopple. Former town Councilman Clifford P
Schneider, an independent, is running as a right – in.
Sunday, October 14, 2007
VOTERS FOR WIND BACKS PROJECT IN CAPE VINCENT
Watertown Daily Times (NY)
October 14, 2007
VOTERS FOR WIND BACKS PROJECT IN CAPE VINCENT
Author: KELLY VADNEY
TIMES STAFF WRITER
Edition: Both
Section: Jefferson
Page: B5
Dateline: CHAUMONT
Article Text:
A new citizens group that supports wind power made its public debut Saturday at an open house for the Cape Vincent Wind Farm.
Voters for Wind has been meeting quietly in Three Mile Bay since June, according to Chairwoman Beth A. White. There are about 20 people in the group, she said.
"We thought this open house was a perfect forum for us to start promoting our group," Mrs. White said.
The group's mission is to promote the Cape Vincent Wind Farm. While Voters for Wind is concerned only with the proposal put forward by BP Alternative Energy, it may one day expand its mission statement to include supporting other wind farms, Mrs. White said.
There are three wind farm proposals in Jefferson County. The St. Lawrence Wind Farm and Cape Vincent Wind Farm are both in Cape Vincent. Horse Creek Wind Farm would cross town lines between Clayton and Orleans.
[Continue via WDT archives]
October 14, 2007
VOTERS FOR WIND BACKS PROJECT IN CAPE VINCENT
Author: KELLY VADNEY
TIMES STAFF WRITER
Edition: Both
Section: Jefferson
Page: B5
Dateline: CHAUMONT
Article Text:
A new citizens group that supports wind power made its public debut Saturday at an open house for the Cape Vincent Wind Farm.
Voters for Wind has been meeting quietly in Three Mile Bay since June, according to Chairwoman Beth A. White. There are about 20 people in the group, she said.
"We thought this open house was a perfect forum for us to start promoting our group," Mrs. White said.
The group's mission is to promote the Cape Vincent Wind Farm. While Voters for Wind is concerned only with the proposal put forward by BP Alternative Energy, it may one day expand its mission statement to include supporting other wind farms, Mrs. White said.
There are three wind farm proposals in Jefferson County. The St. Lawrence Wind Farm and Cape Vincent Wind Farm are both in Cape Vincent. Horse Creek Wind Farm would cross town lines between Clayton and Orleans.
[Continue via WDT archives]
Protesters turn out at Cape Vincent wind farm open house
link not available~
By Kelly Vadney
Watertown Daily Times
14 October 2007
The Cape Vincent Wind Farm’s open house Saturday was as much a forum for protest as it was a pursuit of information.
Dozens of residents attended the open house put on by BP Alternative Energy, the company that has proposed the wind farm. Many attendees used the event not only to glean information, but to express their opinions about wind power.
Inside the Chaumont fire hall, Voters for Wind, a citizens group that promotes the Cape Vincent Wind Farm, held a bake sale and handed out pro-wind-farm signs and refrigerator magnets.
[Continue reading via the WDT archives]
By Kelly Vadney
Watertown Daily Times
14 October 2007
The Cape Vincent Wind Farm’s open house Saturday was as much a forum for protest as it was a pursuit of information.
Dozens of residents attended the open house put on by BP Alternative Energy, the company that has proposed the wind farm. Many attendees used the event not only to glean information, but to express their opinions about wind power.
Inside the Chaumont fire hall, Voters for Wind, a citizens group that promotes the Cape Vincent Wind Farm, held a bake sale and handed out pro-wind-farm signs and refrigerator magnets.
[Continue reading via the WDT archives]
War over Wind Heats up in Lyme
wwnytv.net
14 October 2007
It’s a war over wind turbines and it’s being waged among neighbors.
The debate has been heated in Cape Vincent over a proposed wind farm, and now it is heating up in the Town of Lyme.
British Petroleum presented plans Saturday for the wind farm that would stretch across both towns.
Meanwhile, outside some Town of Lyme resident took the opportunity to shout their opposition.
The protesters not only knocked the wind farm proposal, but they also called out neighbors who support bringing wind power into the neighborhood.
British Petroleum wants to put up 140 wind turbines in the area.
While protesters say they will stand up to anyone who supports the idea, property owners who look forward to the wind power wind fall say they won’t stand down.
The plans for the wind farm are still in the early stages according to British Petroleum. The plans specifically for the Town of Lyme won’t be completed until December.
Zoning still has to be approved as well and construction wouldn’t begin until 2009.
14 October 2007
It’s a war over wind turbines and it’s being waged among neighbors.
The debate has been heated in Cape Vincent over a proposed wind farm, and now it is heating up in the Town of Lyme.
British Petroleum presented plans Saturday for the wind farm that would stretch across both towns.
Meanwhile, outside some Town of Lyme resident took the opportunity to shout their opposition.
The protesters not only knocked the wind farm proposal, but they also called out neighbors who support bringing wind power into the neighborhood.
British Petroleum wants to put up 140 wind turbines in the area.
While protesters say they will stand up to anyone who supports the idea, property owners who look forward to the wind power wind fall say they won’t stand down.
The plans for the wind farm are still in the early stages according to British Petroleum. The plans specifically for the Town of Lyme won’t be completed until December.
Zoning still has to be approved as well and construction wouldn’t begin until 2009.
Friday, October 12, 2007
CAPE VINCENT DEBATES WIND TURBINE ZONING
Published: October 12, 2007
CAPE VINCENT DEBATES WIND TURBINE ZONING
RENEWED EFFORT: TOWN COUNCIL SAYS IT HOPES TO DRAFT NEW REGULATION PLAN BY EARLY NEXT YEAR
By KELLY VADNEY
TIMES STAFF WRITER
CAPE VINCENT -- The Town Council has agreed to renew its efforts to adopt zoning regulations for wind turbines, but exactly how they would be enacted is a source of bitter debate.
Both Wind Power Ethics Group Chairman Urban C. Hirschey and former Town Councilman Clifford P. Schneider urged the council Wednesday to adopt zoning for turbines.
[Continue via the WDT archives]
Thursday, September 27, 2007
Turbine poll blows lukewarm
By Kelly Vadney
Watertown Daily Times
27 September 2007
Most Lyme residents welcome wind farms, but not necessarily in their own backyards.
According to recent survey results, 52 percent of property owners in Lyme say industrial wind turbine development in town is acceptable, but only 37 percent want turbines in their own neighborhoods.
Continue via the [WDT archives]
Watertown Daily Times
27 September 2007
Most Lyme residents welcome wind farms, but not necessarily in their own backyards.
According to recent survey results, 52 percent of property owners in Lyme say industrial wind turbine development in town is acceptable, but only 37 percent want turbines in their own neighborhoods.
Continue via the [WDT archives]
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
Three Lobby county for Wind turbine law
Watertown Daily Times
Jude Seymour
Publication Date: 09/19/2007
Vexed by inconsistent wind turbine regulations among towns, three Jefferson County residents asked legislators Tuesday to establish county-wide zoning laws for industrial turbines.
There’s just one problem. The county has no authority to impose zoning laws on its municipalities.
[Continue via the WDT archives]
Jude Seymour
Publication Date: 09/19/2007
Vexed by inconsistent wind turbine regulations among towns, three Jefferson County residents asked legislators Tuesday to establish county-wide zoning laws for industrial turbines.
There’s just one problem. The county has no authority to impose zoning laws on its municipalities.
[Continue via the WDT archives]
Wednesday, August 29, 2007
Wind Power Ethics Group is deciding if it will appeal
By Kelly Vadney
Watertown Times
29 August 2007
The Wind Power Ethics Group is deciding this week if it will appeal a state Supreme Court judge’s decision that effectively allows wind farms close to Lake Ontario and the St. Lawrence River.
Judge Hugh A. Gilbert handed down a decision Friday that upholds the town Zoning Board of Appeals’ February decision that classifies turbines as utilities under the town’s existing zoning law.
[continue reading via WDT archives]
Watertown Times
29 August 2007
The Wind Power Ethics Group is deciding this week if it will appeal a state Supreme Court judge’s decision that effectively allows wind farms close to Lake Ontario and the St. Lawrence River.
Judge Hugh A. Gilbert handed down a decision Friday that upholds the town Zoning Board of Appeals’ February decision that classifies turbines as utilities under the town’s existing zoning law.
[continue reading via WDT archives]
Friday, August 24, 2007
Meeting urges wind farm zoning, careful thought
August 24, 2007 • New York
CLAYTON — No town should proceed with wind farm development without careful consideration, research and a zoning law that regulates wind towers, participants were told at an informational meeting Thursday.
The Wind Power Ethics Group, a citizens organization that has opposed wind farm development in Cape Vincent, organized the meeting. Just under 200 people attended, according to organizers.
Thousand Islands HS.Meeting urges wind Farm zoning, carefull thought
By Kelly Vadney
Watertown Daily Times
08/24/2007
CLAYTON — No town should proceed with wind farm development without careful consideration, research and a zoning law that regulates wind towers, participants were told at an informational meeting Thursday.
The Wind Power Ethics Group, a citizens organization that has opposed wind farm development in Cape Vincent, organized the meeting. Just under 200 people attended, according to organizers.
[continue reading via the WDT]
Watertown Daily Times
08/24/2007
CLAYTON — No town should proceed with wind farm development without careful consideration, research and a zoning law that regulates wind towers, participants were told at an informational meeting Thursday.
The Wind Power Ethics Group, a citizens organization that has opposed wind farm development in Cape Vincent, organized the meeting. Just under 200 people attended, according to organizers.
[continue reading via the WDT]
Sunday, August 19, 2007
Cape vincent Wind Turbine Lawsuit Argued
By Kelly Vadney
Times Staff Writer
The Watertown Daily Times
19 August 2007
CAPE VINCENT — The Wind Power Ethics Group should know within two months if its lawsuit against the town Zoning Board of Appeals has been successful.
Both sides presented arguments Thursday in state Supreme Court in front of Judge Hugh A. Gilbert.
[continue reading via the Watertown Time archives]
Times Staff Writer
The Watertown Daily Times
19 August 2007
CAPE VINCENT — The Wind Power Ethics Group should know within two months if its lawsuit against the town Zoning Board of Appeals has been successful.
Both sides presented arguments Thursday in state Supreme Court in front of Judge Hugh A. Gilbert.
[continue reading via the Watertown Time archives]
Friday, August 17, 2007
Wind farm plans won't wait for Lyme
link not available
By Kelly Vadney
Publication: Watertown Daily Times (Watertown, NY)
Publication Date: 08/17/2007
CAPE VINCENT — BP Alternative Energy isn’t letting the town of Lyme’s moratorium on wind power halt progress on its proposed Cape Vincent Wind Farm.
The company moved forward with the state environmental review process for the wind farm with the Cape Vincent Planning Board on Wednesday. It submitted a scoping document, which explains what studies it will do in its environmental review. The public has 30 days to submit comments on the scoping material.
[continue reading via the WDT]
By Kelly Vadney
Publication: Watertown Daily Times (Watertown, NY)
Publication Date: 08/17/2007
CAPE VINCENT — BP Alternative Energy isn’t letting the town of Lyme’s moratorium on wind power halt progress on its proposed Cape Vincent Wind Farm.
The company moved forward with the state environmental review process for the wind farm with the Cape Vincent Planning Board on Wednesday. It submitted a scoping document, which explains what studies it will do in its environmental review. The public has 30 days to submit comments on the scoping material.
[continue reading via the WDT]
Thursday, August 16, 2007
Wind Power Informational Meeting
August 16, 2007
Press release- for immediate release
There will be a Wind Power Informational Meeting on August 23rd at 7-9pm
Location: Thousand Islands High School, County Rte 9, Cape Vincent, NY
This meeting will be sponsored by WPEG, a Cape Vincent organization concerned about the implications of major wind development in the Jefferson County Coastal areas.
The pros and cons of wind power development will be discussed along with how a PILOT (Payment in Lieu of Taxes) operates for communities – now and in the future.
Keith Pitman, President and CEO, Empire State Wind Energy, Oneida, NY
Brad Jones, MBA, Consultant, Naples, NY
Paul E. Carr, Ph.D., P. E, Engineer, Professor, Cornell University
James Fayle, Executive Director, Jefferson County Industrial Development Agency (JCIDA)
The panel will be moderated by Denise Young, Director- The Center for Community Studies, Jefferson Community College, Watertown, NY
All residents are urged to attend to learn more about Wind Power Development
Press release- for immediate release
There will be a Wind Power Informational Meeting on August 23rd at 7-9pm
Location: Thousand Islands High School, County Rte 9, Cape Vincent, NY
This meeting will be sponsored by WPEG, a Cape Vincent organization concerned about the implications of major wind development in the Jefferson County Coastal areas.
The pros and cons of wind power development will be discussed along with how a PILOT (Payment in Lieu of Taxes) operates for communities – now and in the future.
Keith Pitman, President and CEO, Empire State Wind Energy, Oneida, NY
Brad Jones, MBA, Consultant, Naples, NY
Paul E. Carr, Ph.D., P. E, Engineer, Professor, Cornell University
James Fayle, Executive Director, Jefferson County Industrial Development Agency (JCIDA)
The panel will be moderated by Denise Young, Director- The Center for Community Studies, Jefferson Community College, Watertown, NY
All residents are urged to attend to learn more about Wind Power Development
Tuesday, August 14, 2007
Cape Board of Trustees/ Discuss turbine issues dock ~
VILLAGE OF CAPE VINCENT BOARD OF TRUSTEES AUGUST 14, 2007
Mayor Timothy D. Maloney opened the meeting at 5:30 PM with Trustees Robert Doud, Douglas Putnam, Alan Ada, and Joseph Gould present.
Mayor Maloney first announced the public hearing for the amendment to Local Law 2-05 would be held on August 28th, as advertised.
Trustee Doud would like the previous minutes corrected to read increased speeding was occurring on Lee St., not James Street. With this correction, Trustee Ada made the motion to dispense with the reading of the previous meeting minutes and correct them as written with Trustee Doud seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Abstract three was given for the Board to review as follows:
General: $26,64550
Water: 13,319.00
Sewer: 7,522.97
After review and questions, Trustee Putnam made the motion to grant the Treasurer authority to pay the abstract with Trustee Gould seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Lucinda Stevens, E. Lake St., addressed the Board with her concern over the use of motorized scooters on Village Streets. Her concern is the operators do not obey traffic laws. Mayor Maloney explained there is a Local Law 4-03 in place to address this use but due to the Village police department being in a transition period it has not been monitored but this would be referred to the officer in charge.
Curfew is also being violated according to Ms.Stevens and should also be monitored by the police. She then complained of an unusual taste and smell with the water at her home. She further explained the Village has tested the water with the results showing no unusual problems. Her neighbor’s homes are not affected but the taste and odor have appeared at different times over the past few months at her residence. After discussion, it was decided the Supt. will be notified the next time the problems occur and the water will be tested.
John Defrancesco, resident, stated he received a call from the Watertown Times reporter explaining she had interviewed Trustee Doud who stated the Local Development Corp. (LDC) was against having singlewide mobile homes in the Village. Mr. Defrancesco explained this was his personal opinion, not the opinion of the LDC. Trustee Doud responded he thought this because LDC members heavily attended the public hearing. As the discussion continued, Trustee Doud stated to Mr. Defrancesco, he does have issues with local group as he feels the group is more concerned with political issues than local development issues. His foremost issue is the recent survey sent out by the group, which he considers a windmill survey, private meetings and the alleged fraud of survey results. Mayor Maloney then used the gavel to end the dialogue by Mr. Doud and announced there would be no more discussion over a newspaper article. Mayor Maloney suggested Mr. Doud go to the next LDC meeting and discuss his issues with the group.
Marty Mason, DPW Supt., reported on activities of his departments as follows:
1. Cut and capped unused sewer laterals
2. Slurry paving of 4500 feet of streets will be done for approx. $8696.00
3. Bernier and Carr will locate survey pins for paving
4. Employee studying for sewer test while off on medical leave
5. Summer Employee G. Mingle will end employment during October or earlier
6. New mower has arrived and is being used
7. Hanging flower pots will come down in mid September
8. Trustee Ada asked the Supt. to order a sign for Broadway and James St. possibly from the County
9. Hylift pump for water plant has been rebuilt and will be delivered
Trustee Doud reported on the recent mobile home survey sent out in July. Out of approximately 450 surveys sent out 213 were returned. The singlewide manufactured home results were 104 votes no and 116 votes yes. The doublewide manufactured home results were 141 yes votes and 79 no votes. Mr. Doud reported the surveys were safeguarded after the question was asked. Mayor Maloney and the Board will take into consideration the written comments that were returned with survey.
Mayor Maloney had received correspondence from the New York State Department of Transportation concerning the proposed Welcome Center building at the East End Park. They questioned whether or not the Village would proceed with the project or return the funding. Trustee Gould made the motion to return the funding as the project had been cancelled with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes. Mayor Maloney will notify the proper officials with Department of Transportation.
Trustee Putnam brought forth for discussion the project scope and budget of the possible construction of a shipping dock at the East End Park. He reported the dock would be 600 feet long with a varying width from 60 feet to 80 feet with a preliminary construction budget of $8,223,000. Mayor Maloney explained the dock would be used to unload windmill parts and also as a Village dock for public use. Trustee Ada stated the dock would benefit the Village as it would encourage tourism and would be useful for tour boats to visit the area and private boaters to which would be of benefit to the Village. Resident, Barb Steinhouse, questioned the fact a portion of the East End Park would be termed commercial while Mayor Maloney explained the Village must show another area in the Village which would be used to compensate for the use of space at the Park. The area would be of the same dollar value and be designated as recreational use. Trustee Putnam will go forward and discuss this dock further with the St. Lawrence Wind Farm officials who have had preliminary interest in the project. He will also contact the New York State Office of Parks and Recreation with the proposed plan. The question of financing the study arose with Mayor Maloney responding it would be the Village responsibility. Residents asked if there would be a public hearing on the project before the Village moves forward with the Mayor responding he will check the possibility of a hearing with legal sources.
Mayor Maloney answered questions that arose at the last meeting about a dock and fence at the Defrancesco property. He did find the Village had issued a permit and Department of Environmental Conservation has no jurisdiction over this area as it was incorporated into the Village in 1987 as part of Village zoning. Trustee Doud did check the fence and found it did not obstruct views with Mr. Defrancesco responding he also had a permit from the Village for a fence.
Mayor Maloney showed the Jefferson County Board of Legislators had transferred paperwork designating a portion of the Dreswick property on Bay Street to the Village. A use of a home in the residential area, which is claimed to being used as a boarding house with, out a proper permit, was discussed. Trustee Doud stated boarding homes are addressed in the code and he will check for the proper language. Trustee Ada made the motion to have the code Enforcement Officer send a letter to the offender with Trustee Doud seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Written correspondence was read from the president of Mimakar Inc. requesting the Board to rescind the parking ban on James Street in front of the Hinckley residence as it is being abused by the Hinckley’s and not enforced by the local police. Trustee Gould stated this had been addressed previously and the Local law will remain and the Village Police will be asked to monitor this area.
James Docteur, Code Officer, advised the Board the Village does not have subdivision laws for a proposed development off Broadway but the project must abide by NYS laws. The Village does not require a site plan review but the Village Board may vote to have a site plan review for comments only. The officer further stated the project is possibly three years out.
Mayor Maloney read a letter of resignation from Perry Golden, part time police officer, but the letter was not signed, just typed and will be returned for a written signature. A Thank You letter will be sent to Mr. Golden for years of service. Mr. Golden will be directed to turn the Village owned weapon over to the Jefferson County Sheriff’s office for safekeeping.
A letter of congratulations will be sent to the Improvement League on their securing a $200,000.00 Downtown Revitalization grant.
Mayor Maloney requested the Board rescind the resolution of May 8, 2007 that stated the Village would withdraw support to the LDC if meetings were not open to the public. He wishes the Board would extend the same trust the Village gives other groups whom the Village makes a monetary contribution. Mayor Maloney believes there was some misconception over the past months with the group and community. Trustee Ada asked how long the group had been organized which is three years and he feels this group is still in its infancy, which could account for some of the problems. Trustee Doud stated it is a moot point as now the meetings are public but did question when the strategy plan would be completed. The plan presentation will be at the September 11th Board meeting. After short discussion, Trustee Doud made the motion to rescind his motion of May 8th with Trustee Gould seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Gould will order digital service for Internet connections for the Law offices, Village office and the DPW offices.
Trustee Gould made the motion to enter an executive session to discuss policing issues with Officer Ryan at 7:25 PM with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes. Trustee Ada made the motion to appoint Shawn Ryan as Officer in charge with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes. Trustee Gould made the motion to increase the hourly rate of Shawn Ryan, due to an increase in duties to $15.00 per hour retroactive to August 8, 2007 with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Ada made the motion to resume regular session at 8:24 Pm with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Gould made the motion to allow the Village to participate in the New York State deferred Compensation Plan with Trustee Doud seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Doud made the motion to adjourn at 8:30 PM with Mayor Maloney seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Respectfully submitted,
Nancy Knapp
Village Clerk
Mayor Timothy D. Maloney opened the meeting at 5:30 PM with Trustees Robert Doud, Douglas Putnam, Alan Ada, and Joseph Gould present.
Mayor Maloney first announced the public hearing for the amendment to Local Law 2-05 would be held on August 28th, as advertised.
Trustee Doud would like the previous minutes corrected to read increased speeding was occurring on Lee St., not James Street. With this correction, Trustee Ada made the motion to dispense with the reading of the previous meeting minutes and correct them as written with Trustee Doud seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Abstract three was given for the Board to review as follows:
General: $26,64550
Water: 13,319.00
Sewer: 7,522.97
After review and questions, Trustee Putnam made the motion to grant the Treasurer authority to pay the abstract with Trustee Gould seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Lucinda Stevens, E. Lake St., addressed the Board with her concern over the use of motorized scooters on Village Streets. Her concern is the operators do not obey traffic laws. Mayor Maloney explained there is a Local Law 4-03 in place to address this use but due to the Village police department being in a transition period it has not been monitored but this would be referred to the officer in charge.
Curfew is also being violated according to Ms.Stevens and should also be monitored by the police. She then complained of an unusual taste and smell with the water at her home. She further explained the Village has tested the water with the results showing no unusual problems. Her neighbor’s homes are not affected but the taste and odor have appeared at different times over the past few months at her residence. After discussion, it was decided the Supt. will be notified the next time the problems occur and the water will be tested.
John Defrancesco, resident, stated he received a call from the Watertown Times reporter explaining she had interviewed Trustee Doud who stated the Local Development Corp. (LDC) was against having singlewide mobile homes in the Village. Mr. Defrancesco explained this was his personal opinion, not the opinion of the LDC. Trustee Doud responded he thought this because LDC members heavily attended the public hearing. As the discussion continued, Trustee Doud stated to Mr. Defrancesco, he does have issues with local group as he feels the group is more concerned with political issues than local development issues. His foremost issue is the recent survey sent out by the group, which he considers a windmill survey, private meetings and the alleged fraud of survey results. Mayor Maloney then used the gavel to end the dialogue by Mr. Doud and announced there would be no more discussion over a newspaper article. Mayor Maloney suggested Mr. Doud go to the next LDC meeting and discuss his issues with the group.
Marty Mason, DPW Supt., reported on activities of his departments as follows:
1. Cut and capped unused sewer laterals
2. Slurry paving of 4500 feet of streets will be done for approx. $8696.00
3. Bernier and Carr will locate survey pins for paving
4. Employee studying for sewer test while off on medical leave
5. Summer Employee G. Mingle will end employment during October or earlier
6. New mower has arrived and is being used
7. Hanging flower pots will come down in mid September
8. Trustee Ada asked the Supt. to order a sign for Broadway and James St. possibly from the County
9. Hylift pump for water plant has been rebuilt and will be delivered
Trustee Doud reported on the recent mobile home survey sent out in July. Out of approximately 450 surveys sent out 213 were returned. The singlewide manufactured home results were 104 votes no and 116 votes yes. The doublewide manufactured home results were 141 yes votes and 79 no votes. Mr. Doud reported the surveys were safeguarded after the question was asked. Mayor Maloney and the Board will take into consideration the written comments that were returned with survey.
Mayor Maloney had received correspondence from the New York State Department of Transportation concerning the proposed Welcome Center building at the East End Park. They questioned whether or not the Village would proceed with the project or return the funding. Trustee Gould made the motion to return the funding as the project had been cancelled with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes. Mayor Maloney will notify the proper officials with Department of Transportation.
Trustee Putnam brought forth for discussion the project scope and budget of the possible construction of a shipping dock at the East End Park. He reported the dock would be 600 feet long with a varying width from 60 feet to 80 feet with a preliminary construction budget of $8,223,000. Mayor Maloney explained the dock would be used to unload windmill parts and also as a Village dock for public use. Trustee Ada stated the dock would benefit the Village as it would encourage tourism and would be useful for tour boats to visit the area and private boaters to which would be of benefit to the Village. Resident, Barb Steinhouse, questioned the fact a portion of the East End Park would be termed commercial while Mayor Maloney explained the Village must show another area in the Village which would be used to compensate for the use of space at the Park. The area would be of the same dollar value and be designated as recreational use. Trustee Putnam will go forward and discuss this dock further with the St. Lawrence Wind Farm officials who have had preliminary interest in the project. He will also contact the New York State Office of Parks and Recreation with the proposed plan. The question of financing the study arose with Mayor Maloney responding it would be the Village responsibility. Residents asked if there would be a public hearing on the project before the Village moves forward with the Mayor responding he will check the possibility of a hearing with legal sources.
Mayor Maloney answered questions that arose at the last meeting about a dock and fence at the Defrancesco property. He did find the Village had issued a permit and Department of Environmental Conservation has no jurisdiction over this area as it was incorporated into the Village in 1987 as part of Village zoning. Trustee Doud did check the fence and found it did not obstruct views with Mr. Defrancesco responding he also had a permit from the Village for a fence.
Mayor Maloney showed the Jefferson County Board of Legislators had transferred paperwork designating a portion of the Dreswick property on Bay Street to the Village. A use of a home in the residential area, which is claimed to being used as a boarding house with, out a proper permit, was discussed. Trustee Doud stated boarding homes are addressed in the code and he will check for the proper language. Trustee Ada made the motion to have the code Enforcement Officer send a letter to the offender with Trustee Doud seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Written correspondence was read from the president of Mimakar Inc. requesting the Board to rescind the parking ban on James Street in front of the Hinckley residence as it is being abused by the Hinckley’s and not enforced by the local police. Trustee Gould stated this had been addressed previously and the Local law will remain and the Village Police will be asked to monitor this area.
James Docteur, Code Officer, advised the Board the Village does not have subdivision laws for a proposed development off Broadway but the project must abide by NYS laws. The Village does not require a site plan review but the Village Board may vote to have a site plan review for comments only. The officer further stated the project is possibly three years out.
Mayor Maloney read a letter of resignation from Perry Golden, part time police officer, but the letter was not signed, just typed and will be returned for a written signature. A Thank You letter will be sent to Mr. Golden for years of service. Mr. Golden will be directed to turn the Village owned weapon over to the Jefferson County Sheriff’s office for safekeeping.
A letter of congratulations will be sent to the Improvement League on their securing a $200,000.00 Downtown Revitalization grant.
Mayor Maloney requested the Board rescind the resolution of May 8, 2007 that stated the Village would withdraw support to the LDC if meetings were not open to the public. He wishes the Board would extend the same trust the Village gives other groups whom the Village makes a monetary contribution. Mayor Maloney believes there was some misconception over the past months with the group and community. Trustee Ada asked how long the group had been organized which is three years and he feels this group is still in its infancy, which could account for some of the problems. Trustee Doud stated it is a moot point as now the meetings are public but did question when the strategy plan would be completed. The plan presentation will be at the September 11th Board meeting. After short discussion, Trustee Doud made the motion to rescind his motion of May 8th with Trustee Gould seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Gould will order digital service for Internet connections for the Law offices, Village office and the DPW offices.
Trustee Gould made the motion to enter an executive session to discuss policing issues with Officer Ryan at 7:25 PM with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes. Trustee Ada made the motion to appoint Shawn Ryan as Officer in charge with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes. Trustee Gould made the motion to increase the hourly rate of Shawn Ryan, due to an increase in duties to $15.00 per hour retroactive to August 8, 2007 with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Ada made the motion to resume regular session at 8:24 Pm with Trustee Putnam seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Gould made the motion to allow the Village to participate in the New York State deferred Compensation Plan with Trustee Doud seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Trustee Doud made the motion to adjourn at 8:30 PM with Mayor Maloney seconding the motion and all voting yes.
Respectfully submitted,
Nancy Knapp
Village Clerk
Saturday, August 4, 2007
Property Owners Asked For Input On Wind Farm Turbines
By Kelly Vadney
Publication: Watertown Daily Times (Watertown, NY)
Publication Date: 08/04/2007
CHAUMONT — Residents in Lyme will have the opportunity to express their views on wind farm development this month.
This week, the town Planning Board is sending surveys to all property owners asking where wind turbines should be sited.
[Continue via the WDT archives]
Publication: Watertown Daily Times (Watertown, NY)
Publication Date: 08/04/2007
CHAUMONT — Residents in Lyme will have the opportunity to express their views on wind farm development this month.
This week, the town Planning Board is sending surveys to all property owners asking where wind turbines should be sited.
[Continue via the WDT archives]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)